Issue #1(15) 2018 Opinion

Why national space laws on the exploitation of resources of celestial bodies contradict international law

Artist’s concept showing NASA’s Space Exploration Vehicle (SEV) on a near-Earth asteroid mission.
Artist’s concept showing NASA’s Space Exploration Vehicle (SEV) on a near-Earth asteroid mission.
Stephan Hobe Institute of Air and Space Law, University of Cologne, Germany

Both the US Commercial Space Launch Act of 2015 and the Luxemburg Law on the Exploration and Use of Space Resources of 2017 stress that they are in conformity with the framework of international law. But is that really true? In the following article Stephan Hobe argues that such is not the case.

It goes beyond the traditional argument that the letters of international legislation governing activities in outer space are either not accepted by the respective countries (Moon Agreement) or are too general and too inexplicit to articulate such prohibition (the Outer Space Treaty).

It is true that Article II of the Outer Space Treaty explicitly prohibits the national appropriation of outer space and the celestial bodies by means of sovereignty, by means of use or by any other means. Thereby only the notion of sovereignty is fully clear. Article II prohibits in fact the taking of areas of celestial bodies as well as in outer space. The idea behind this is that the Outer Space Treaty tries to avoid any claim to exclusivity.

Exclusive claims of states are not in line with the legal nature of outer space as a legal common, which means that outer space and the celestial bodies cannot be appropriated by a single country. And then this provision continues that appropriation also by means of use is prohibited. Here, it is unclear where the Outer Space Treaty exactly stands. Only through a systematic interpretation it may become clear that two contradictory provisions cannot have been the intention of the founders of the Outer Space Treaty.

To continue reading this premium article, subscribe now for unlimited access to all online content

If you already have a login and password to access www.room.eu.com - Please log in to be able to read all the articles of the site.

Popular articles

See also

Environment

Recipe for success on flights to Mars

Lounge

Panoramas from the surface of the Moon

Security

Down to Earth: how to deorbit satellites and save money

Popular articles

Security

Flouting the rules on satellite registrations

ESA astronaut Samantha Cristoforetti’s photo of the UK from the International Space Station. Opinion

Rediscovering UK sovereign launch capability

Artist’s concept of a US Coast Guard cutter illuminating Arctic icebergs. Security

Guardians of the galaxy