Issue #1(15) 2018 Astronautics

Space safety – the problem with dual hatting

Vincent M Brannigan University of Maryland College Park, USA

The US Government Accountability Office (GAO) recently criticised NASA for continuing a dual hatting approach to operations and safety in its human spaceflight ESD (Exploration Systems and Development) programme which will transport crews to the Moon and beyond. Dual hatting has multiple meanings in different contexts. For example, it is often used in a context where the same person has multiple operational roles. But for this article dual hatting will be limited to the case where the same person has both operational and safety regulatory responsibility. In NASA language these are programmatic and technical authority roles. Such dual hatting has been a problem in many areas.

Dual hatting can kill people. On 14 April 1912 at 9.05 pm, about two and a half hours before the RMS Titanic collided with an iceberg, the SS Californian sent the British passenger liner a severe ice warning stating, ‘We are stopped and surrounded by ice’. The reply from the Titanic was, ‘Shut up, shut up, I am busy; I am working Cape Race’. In other words, ‘don’t bother me with that safety stuff’.

So why would the radio operator ignore a safety warning? The reason is simple. The Titanic’s operator was an employee of the Marconi company managing lucrative commercial traffic. The radio operators were not part of the ‘deck’ department navigating the ship but instead were part of the ‘stewards’ department, there primarily to serve the passengers’ radio needs. Operational demands clearly trumped safety issues.

There is almost always an inherent conflict between getting the job done and doing things safely and the fundamental problem of dual hatting in safety regulation has been known since ancient times.

To continue reading this premium article, subscribe now for unlimited access to all online content

If you already have a login and password to access - Please log in to be able to read all the articles of the site.

Popular articles

See also


Data Systems to Support Early Warning of Spaceborne Emergency Situations


Unlocking the potential of annular ion engines


Mining outer space may be cool but is it legal?

Popular articles

The Arecibo radio telescope showing the Gregorian dual-reflector feed and two of the three support towers. Science

Arecibo - an astounding legacy

Artistic interpretation of Lunar Gateway, a habitable station in lunar orbit that will be critical to sustainable lunar exploration and will serve as a model for future missions to Mars. Specials

A shared vision for space exploration